First off, a Japanese lesson for y'all. It isn't pronounced Key-o-to or To-key-o. "Kyo" is pronounced exactly like it's spelled: make the sound of the letter K then say yo as in yo-yo, and blend the two together. Kyoto, Tokyo. I can't tell you how much it annoys me when people screw that up, and both Kerry and Bush did it tonight.
Anyway...who won? My brain wants to call it a tie, but my gut says Bush won. Don't get me wrong, he's a goddamn lying son of a motherfucking bitch and every word out of his mouth was horseshit, but Americans seem to eat that shit up. Kerry was on the defensive most of the time, which isn't how it should be. It's interesting though, I thought Kerry handled the foriegn policy questions better than Bush and that Bush handled the domestic policy questions better than Kerry, which, of course, goes against "conventional" wisdom. Here are some excerpt from the notes I took during the debate (yes I took notes during the debate...I never deny that I am a true geek):
1. The questions were, for the most part, fantastic. Some of them were stupid (the "are you wishy washy" question to Kerry) and some of them obviously were not written by undecided voters (both the abortion and stem cell questions were clearly written by strong pro-lifers- people that would never vote for Kerry). But for the most part they were very insightful. The question about the draft gave Kerry a great opportunity to talk about the "back-door draft" of the national reserves, an issue that has largely been left out of the debate thus far.
2. During the first half of the debate, Bush was REALLY confrontational. He was so didactic towards the questioners. It was like he was lecturing them. And did you notice that he snapped at the moderator? That ain't good form, especially when you proceed to make a shitty point. Also, it seemed like he never talked to Kerry; never addressed him directly. It was always "my opponent says this, my opponent says that." Kerry, on the other hand, did a much better job connecting with the audience during the first half. He made it a point to respond to each questioner with their name, something I didn't notice Bush do once.
3. Things started to flip around for the second half though. Bush was more personable, cracked a few jokes, and kept the conversation on Kerry's record, not his own. And when he had to talk about his own record, he just lied trough his teeth: "I am a good steward of the land."?!?!?!?!? Does anyone, anywhere, honestly beieve that Bush's enviromental policy has been in anyway beneficial to the actual enviroment? Didn't think so.
4. So. Bush wants a Judge that would be against the Dred Scott Decision. I was very pround that the president tonight took a bold stand against....slavery? What the fuck? It isn't 1864, it's 2004. That was the most fucked up moment of the evening, I think, and one of the few gaffes that will probably hurt Bush's showing in the domestic half.
5. Favorite slips and fuck ups of the evening- Kerry mimed brain surgery when he said "Brain surgeon." Bush called "Senator Kennedy the most liberal senator," when he clearly meant Kerry (freudian slip...). "There's a rumor out there on the Internets.." Bush said "Fastle." I have no idea in what context, and since the word bears no resemblance to any other word, I'm not sure what to make of it.
6. Even though I think the public perception will be that Bush won (and that's all that really matters), on policy issues, Kerry clearly won. The best points he made: 1. In response to the question of Iran's nuclear ambition, Kerry didn't take the easy road and chew out Bush for not being tough enough. Instead, he focused on the much less sexy, but much bigger, threat: North Korea. 2. The aformentioned "back-door draft." 3. His systematic destruction of Bush's enviromental record. In particular, his point that the skies would be cleaner had the "Clear Skies" intiative not been passed. 4 And my favorite: the way he answered the abortion question. He came off as a pro-lifer that doesn't believe in legislating morality, which is about the most main stream position there is. He also brought up Bush's disastorous record in regards to supporting family planning abroad, another issue that isn't discussed nearly enough.
7. Did you notice that Kerry didn't ever explicitly mention his service in Vietnam? He vaguly referred to it once or twice, but, on the whole, hardly mentioned it.
Again, I really, really hope I'm wrong. But I think Bush nailed it tonight. He had much, much lower expectations to live up to this time. He had to not look like a total idiot, and, to someone ignorant of the facts (and how can you be undecided if you ae ignorant of the facts), he came off as calm, intelligent, and more stable leader. Ugh.
Spewed by
Spew Master »
»
Link
»